ESOP
VSOP
Examples
Solutions

Employee recruitment through employee stock ownership - a powerful tool for German SMEs

Dr. Christopher Hahn
This article was last updated on: 29.05.2023

In recent years, German SMEs have had a huge problem: attracting new employees. It is even more difficult to attract skilled workers if you cannot pay high salaries. Nevertheless, you have the opportunity to attract top trained specialists - namely with employee share ownership.
Employee share ownership means that you give your employees a share in the success of the company. Often this is done as compensation for a lower salary. Such employee participation must be contractually defined. You have a choice of programs, such as a VSOP participation or participation under share options in an ESOP. In this guide, we explain what these abbreviations mean and go into detail about what employee share ownership is and what you should look out for.

Employee Share Ownership Definition: What are Employee Share Ownership Plans?

The concept of employee share ownership is generally understood to mean the participation of employees in a company's success in material form. There are various forms of employee share ownership. All of them have the overriding objective of allowing employees to participate in the company's profits or in its increase in value. The reasons for introducing employee share ownership can be many and varied.
In the case of employee share ownership in a startup, the introduction can make sense because the young company is not yet able to pay huge salaries but still does not want to do without top-qualified specialists. In the case of an employee participation GmbH, the focus is usually on incentivizing, motivating and increasing employee satisfaction and loyalty to the company.
Long-established companies, on the other hand, benefit from an employee participation GmbH in the form of better work performance and closer employee loyalty to the company. Ideally, a participation program should be a win-win situation for both sides, with both the employer and the employee benefiting. You can choose from a number of different variants. A basic distinction is made between:

  • real employee participation
  • virtual enterprise participation

While a real employee stock ownership program means a real participation in the company, for example in the form of shares or stock options, a virtual employee stock ownership program only allows an indirect participation in the company.


1. real direct employee participation
Direct employee participation is the classic and gives the employee a real stake in the company. The employee is given the opportunity to become a shareholder in the company. This is easy, for example, with a stock corporation that is listed on the stock exchange. Here, shares or stock options are issued. However, since many medium-sized companies tend to be corporate legal forms such as limited liability companies or related models, shares are not typically issued here. However, it is still possible to give employees a share in the company.
There are various ways of structuring this. Such participation often takes the form of an ESOP (Employee Stock Option Plan). In this case, the company issues shares in the share capital, which in the case of a GmbH is at least 25,000 euros. Under an ESOP, the employee could receive shares of up to five percent of this sum in the form of an employee stock option, for example. A classic ESOP contract specifies what percentage of the share capital can be acquired at what time and under what conditions.
In Germany, however, direct employee participation in a company in the form of real shares or share options involves a great deal of effort, such as the notarization of the transfer of the company shares, and further bureaucratic hurdles. These must be taken into account in order to avoid additional tax burdens, for example. For these reasons, it makes sense to consider alternatives such as virtual employee shareholdings.


2. Virtual shareholding
A virtual employee shareholding (VSOP) is similar to a direct one, but has elementary differences. As the name suggests, employees do not receive real shares, but virtual ones. Nevertheless, this gives them the opportunity to participate in the success of the company. Moreover, employees do not become shareholders. Strictly speaking, these are contracts under the law of obligations that are concluded between the employer and the employee.
The Virtual Stock Option Plan works in a similar way to an ESOP. However, there is no real equity participation for employees, only an entitlement to virtual company shares. With Virtual Stocks, the employer regulates the conditions under which it grants what amount of shares to its employees and what payments they receive. Possible options are:

  • Payments on the sale of the company
  • Payments in the event of profit distributions
  • Payments when the employee leaves

The elementary advantages of virtual participation (VSOP or also VESOP) compared to real participation (ESOP) are

  • Significantly less bureaucracy
  • Higher flexibility
  • no problems with taxation, the employee definitely pays taxes only when he receives a real cash inflow from the participation

In this article, we address the difference between real and virtual shareholdings.

3. other employee participation Examples of employee recruitment
In addition to the options described above, there are other options which are much less common but which we would like to mention for the sake of completeness:

  • Special payment or bonus: A special payment is a simple form of employee participation. It is possible, for example, for you to give your employees a share of the annual profit in the form of a special payment at the end of the year.
  • Profit participation rights: Here, too, employees receive a right to participate in profits. The structuring of such profit participation rights is largely free, as there are hardly any legal regulations that you have to comply with.
  • Employee credit: This is a performance-related employee profit-sharing plan that is not paid out directly but is initially credited to an internal account. The credit balance in this account earns interest on a performance-related or fixed basis. As the employee has no direct income from this, this participation is tax-free.
  • Loan: An employee loan is also a form of participation. In this case, the company grants its employees a loan from its own business assets, for which interest accrues. This interest is agreed on a fixed basis and the interest can, of course, also be performance-related.

Employee recruitment as an acute problem in SMEs
German SMEs are increasingly suffering from the progressive shortage of personnel in all areas. Employees are in a good position vis-à-vis employers and can usually choose from a wide variety of offers. While headhunters used to look exclusively for highly paid specialists for management positions, they now search for employees in all sectors - even unskilled workers are sought in this way.
The reason: nowadays, employees can often choose where and under what conditions they work. If the working atmosphere is not right, if too much overtime is demanded, or if there is no attractive salary, they switch to another industry where working hours are regulated and it is possible to earn more.
Fear of unemployment is no longer a decisive reason for holding on to a job or a company. For this reason, employers need to score points with other benefits, such as flexible working hours, company childcare, affordable housing, a home office or employee share ownership. Gradually, the baby boomers are retiring and experts estimate that there will be around 7 million fewer workers in Germany by 2035.
If the population shrinks, fewer jobs will be needed in some areas, but the acute labor shortage will hit the middle classes particularly hard. In the past, economic growth was achieved by expanding employment in the German economy - this is no longer possible. Even if the shortage of skilled workers does not affect all sectors and regions in Germany, there is an urgent need for action in some sectors.
After all, Germany's SMEs need a strong base of skilled workers in order to secure their business location sustainably and in the long term. Companies are therefore under pressure and the battle for talent is becoming more intense. If you want to attract new employees, you have to fight for them and create incentives.

Employee shareholdings as a solution to the shortage of skilled workers

In times of a shortage of skilled workers, employee retention and recruitment are more important than ever before. You should therefore position yourself as an interesting employer. One way of doing this is employee profit-sharing, which makes you attractive in the long term. Retaining qualified employees in their own company and recruiting employees is a major challenge for many companies. At the same time, the shortage of skilled workers is slowing down the development of companies and the lack of capable employees is noticeable in many economic sectors.
Therefore, employers must offer advantages and positively differentiate themselves from the competition in order to attract experienced employees and retain them in the long term. Employee stock ownership programs are an efficient means of retaining employees and counteracting the shortage of skilled workers. Such programs have long been standard practice abroad, and interest in them is growing in Germany as well.
Involving employees in your company in the form of benefits has become elementarily important in order to remain competitive in the labor market in the future. For these reasons, you should take a look at the different options and variants of employee participation to find the model that suits you personally.
The models all differ from one another, also in terms of the incentive for employees. In addition, the tax treatment is important for employee participation. Not all models are recommended for every company. Furthermore, there are employee participation models that are relatively simple and inexpensive to implement and offer real incentives for employees.

Why employee shareholdings can be so valuable for SMEs

For the company itself, employee shareholdings have numerous advantages. These include, for example:

  1. Increasing employee motivation: If your employees are motivated, they make a decisive contribution to your company. A close employee relationship with the company has a positive effect on the motivation of your employees. The employee's work performance and willingness to work is increased by a financial contribution to the company. As a result, the employee actively participates in the success of the company. He himself benefits from a higher income, which increases employee productivity.
  2. Increase in cash and cash equivalents: Depending on the employee share ownership model, your cash and cash equivalents increase through employee share ownership, such as preferred shares. This is because the employees' investments remain within the company. As a result, you avoid having to obtain outside capital from external lending companies and have an effective way of raising capital.
  3. Bonding with the employer: Because employees share in the company's profits or success, they invest more and participate in the company's success. As a result, a strong bond with the company automatically develops. This close bond results in increased motivation, which leads to lower absenteeism and fluctuation.


There are also various advantages from the employees' point of view. These include a right to a say and a right to information. At the same time, your employees bear greater responsibility and have more freedom to make decisions in their areas of responsibility. Financial participation in the company gives employees the opportunity to earn a higher income. At the same time, employees with a high level of responsibility identify more strongly with their employer. This leads to increased productivity and better motivation. Satisfaction with the employer and the area of responsibility is also increased.

What do you need to pay attention to with employee stock options?

To successfully integrate an employee participation program into your company, you need a strategy. Numerous questions arise not only in the course of implementation, but already during research. For example, what about taxation? Is employee stock ownership tax-free? Where does the sale of employee stock need to be reported on the tax return? Is there a VSOP model contract or a phantom stock model contract?
As a first step, it is advisable to find out whether there is any interest at all in employee share ownership on the part of the workforce. Therefore, you should conduct a corresponding survey. In addition, you must observe legal regulations for employee participation programs. Similarly, your individual circumstances must be taken into account.
You must avoid any tax or social security disadvantages arising from employee participation. Furthermore, the design options vary and require a great deal of research in advance. A dominant topic is, of course, the taxation of employee participation.
Depending on the participation, the employee is then not only in an employment relationship, but is also a shareholder at the same time. You therefore need to clarify what happens in the event of a sale. It therefore makes sense to leave the implementation, starting with the planning of your project, through the contracts and up to the implementation, to experienced experts.

Conclusion: Preventing the shortage of skilled workers with employee share ownership

Of course, employee profit-sharing alone cannot completely counteract the shortage of skilled workers - but it can make it easier and faster to recruit new employees and retain existing top talent in your company. There are various legal requirements that need to be observed when it comes to employee stock ownership plans. In addition, you must of course take your individual wishes and circumstances into account.
If you disregard important aspects, this will have consequences under social security and tax law. It is therefore best to leave the implementation and planning to experts. We will be happy to advise you if you have a fundamental interest in the topic of employee participation.

Disclaimer: The contents of the information offered at esop-direkt.de do not constitute legal advice. If you require a legal review of your individual case, please contact our specialized team: beratung@esop-direkt.de

No items found.
Questions? Talk to our expert!
FREE CONSULTATION
Dr. Christopher Hahn
Lawyer & Author
Your expert for employee benefits
Questions? Talk to our expert!
FREE CONSULTATION
Dr. Christopher Hahn
Lawyer & Author
Your expert for employee benefits
Questions? Talk to our expert!
FREE CONSULTATION
Dr. Christopher Hahn
Lawyer & Author
Your expert for employee benefits
Questions? Talk to our expert!
Dr. Christopher Hahn
Lawyer & author, your expert on employee benefits
FREE CONSULTATION
ESOP & VSOP
As an employer, you may not form tax provisions in accordance with section 249 (1) sentence 1 HGB and section 6 (1) no. 3a letters a) and e). This is because, according to a landmark decision of the BFH dated March 15, 2017, file no. I R 11/15, classic VSOP agreements are obligations subject to a condition precedent.
Questions? Talk to our expert!
Dr. Christopher Hahn
Lawyer & author, your expert on employee benefits
FREE CONSULTATION
ESOP & VSOP
As an employer, you may not form tax provisions in accordance with section 249 (1) sentence 1 HGB and section 6 (1) no. 3a letters a) and e). This is because, according to a landmark decision of the BFH dated March 15, 2017, file no. I R 11/15, classic VSOP agreements are obligations subject to a condition precedent.
Questions? Talk to our expert!
Dr. Christopher Hahn
Lawyer & author, your expert on employee benefits
FREE CONSULTATION
ESOP & VSOP
As an employer, you may not form tax provisions in accordance with section 249 (1) sentence 1 HGB and section 6 (1) no. 3a letters a) and e). This is because, according to a landmark decision of the BFH dated March 15, 2017, file no. I R 11/15, classic VSOP agreements are obligations subject to a condition precedent.
Close
KOSTENFREI & UNVERBINDLICH
Close

Buchen Sie jetzt Ihre Erstberatung

Alternativ - Termin buchen

Sprechen Sie mit unserem Experten:

Kolja Czudnochowski

Founder & Consultant

Mit Absenden des Formulars willige ich in die Verarbeitung meiner Daten gemäß der Datenschutzerklärung ein. Diese Einwilligung kann ich jederzeit widerrufen.
Close
KOSTENFREI & UNVERBINDLICH
Close

Buchen Sie jetzt Ihre Erstberatung

Thank you for your inquiry, we will get back to you as soon as possible.

For urgent questions, please contact +49 30 209 677 94
You are also welcome to book an appointment for your initial consultation directly.
Alternativ - Termin buchen

Sprechen Sie mit unserem Experten:

Kolja Czudnochowski

Founder & Consultant

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again.